Create one bid-leveling sheet
List every required work item and comparison field in rows, then place each proposal in a column. This makes omissions, alternatives, allowances, and qualifications visible before price drives the decision.
Compare these items line by line
- Scope inclusions and measurable quantities
- Preparation, protection, demolition, disposal, and restoration
- Materials, equipment, performance requirements, and substitutions
- Schedule, phasing, working hours, shutdowns, and access
- Project staffing, subcontractors, supervision, and communication
- Permits, inspections, testing, commissioning, and closeout
- Allowances, unit prices, exclusions, taxes, bonds, and insurance
- Warranty, payment schedule, change-order process, and proposal validity
Resolve gaps in writing
Issue the same clarification questions to every bidder and keep the responses with the proposals. If the scope changes, ask all bidders to price the same revision. Avoid relying on informal statements that never become part of the final agreement.
Evaluate fit as well as price
Consider relevant commercial experience, staffing capacity, schedule credibility, safety planning, documentation, communication, and the provider's understanding of occupied-property constraints. Verify licenses, insurance, references, and project requirements using appropriate primary sources.
Sources and official resources
These links are provided for reference and do not imply an endorsement.